Gray Sheep Christianity: Why Compromise Displeases Jesus
- Jack Selcher
- Sep 16, 2025
- 3 min read
Updated: 3 days ago
Summary
A personal story illustrates how subtle compromises can make believers blend in rather than stand out. Jesus rebuked the church at Thyatira for tolerating sin while appearing faithful. He sees through hidden compromises and judges motives and actions. Compromise with the world spreads and destroys spiritual witness. To please Christ, believers must repent and continually change, becoming more like Jesus so others can clearly see the difference He makes.
A Small Compromise with Big Implications
When I was a graduate student, I told a fellow student I was a teetotaler. Word got around. The managers of my housing unit had a Christmas party.
One of them pressured me to sample the punch, assuring me it had no alcohol. She lied. I took one sip. I did not taste anything unusual.
I commented that the drink did not taste like tomato juice, and everyone laughed loudly. I concluded they had spiked the punch by their reaction to what I said. Eventually, I put the cup down, minus one sip, and left.
Gray Sheep Christianity
Everyone relaxed when they thought I was drinking what they were. This is not about drinking alcohol.
It is about compromising our principles. Black sheep can relax when God’s sheep are gray, but we irritate Jesus.
Jesus’ Warning to the Church at Thyatira
Although the Christians at Thyatira had some wonderful qualities, many were gray sheep (Revelation 2:18-29). Christ praised them because their love overflowed in service, and they faithfully persevered through trials. But most of His words to them were about their shortcomings.
He knew the thoughts and intentions of their hearts. Similarly, we cannot hide the blackness of our lives from Him. He does not excuse it.
His feet, like burnished bronze, suggest He pursues and treads down all that is evil. He knows when we are compromising our Christian principles to fit in.
Is your language as “white” at home and work as it is in your house of worship? Do your neighbors and co-workers know you are a Christian? Are you known as a good worker? A good neighbor?
We face the same problems as our unbelieving neighbors. We fulfill our mission by showing them the difference Christ makes.
Why Compromise Always Grows
Jezebel’s false teaching was that it would be foolish to lose a job for not going along with the trade guild’s idolatrous religious requirements. But compromise snowballs. Practicing evil begins by increasingly tolerating it.
Repentance and Continual Change
To please God, we must change. Not to blend into society, but to become more like Jesus.
A relationship with God begins with a change of attitude toward Him called repentance. Once we are God’s children by grace through faith, Satan tries to keep us from changing.
Living So Others See Christ
Meanwhile, God seeks to change us so completely that others can see Christ in us. Christ deals severely with those who refuse to change (Revelation 2:22). What we try to hide from God and others is what we need to confess and repent.
Compromise with the world kills. We cannot hide it. Jesus will judge our motives and actions. Black sheep relax when God’s sheep are gray, but Jesus does not.
Only repentance can turn away His judgment. To make Jesus happy, we must continually change. See additional free spiritual growth resources for Christians.
God has empowered me to write His Power for Your Weakness—260 Steps Toward Spiritual Strength. It’s a free, evangelistic, devotional, and discipleship e-book. Pastors have used it in Malawi, Mozambique, and Zambia to lead 7,590 people to Christ and teach the basics of Christianity to 17,681 people. I invite you to explore and use it in your setting.